Article Text

Download PDFPDF

Managing acne vulgaris: an update
  1. Miriam Santer1,
  2. Esther Burden-Teh2,
  3. Jane Ravenscroft3
  1. 1 Primary Care Research Centre, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK
  2. 2 University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK
  3. 3 Dermatology, Queen's Medical Centre, Nottingham, UK
  1. Correspondence to Professor Miriam Santer, Primary Care Research Centre, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK; M.Santer{at}soton.ac.uk

Abstract

Acne vulgaris is very common and can have significant negative impact on people. While sometimes a transient problem, acne may persist for many years and often leads to permanent scars or pigment changes. Guidelines unanimously advise topical treatments as first-line, although differ in recommending either topical benzoyl peroxide or topical retinoid (mainly adapalene) alone or in combination. Guidance published by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence advises counselling patients regarding avoidance of skin irritation when starting topical treatments and promoting adherence (treatments take 6–8 weeks to work). Oral antibiotics are currently overprescribed for acne but have a role when coprescribed with a non-antibiotic topical treatment. Hormonal treatments, such as the combined contraceptive pill, are also effective and there is growing evidence for the use of spironolactone for women with persistent acne. Recent guidance from the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency regarding isotretinoin has implications for specialist prescribing and monitoring, and increasing public awareness of potential risks of mental health problems and sexual dysfunction. Although acne is associated with psychiatric disorder, the mental health effects of isotretinoin remain controversial.

  • Antimicrobial Stewardship
  • Skin diseases
  • Primary Health Care
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/

This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.

Key learning points

  • Early effective treatment for acne may prevent scarring and pigment changes.

  • Topical treatments are first line for mild/moderate acne but patients need information on how to avoid adverse effects and advice that treatments take 6–8 weeks to work.

  • Oral antibiotics can be used as second-line treatment, or for moderate or severe acne, when coprescribed with a non-antibiotic topical treatment.

  • Most guidelines suggest that duration of oral antibiotics for acne should be limited to 3 months, although National Institute for Health and Care Excellence suggests up to 6 months.

  • Hormonal treatments, such as the combined contraceptive pill, are an alternative treatment for women but can take 3–6 months to work.

  • There is a growing evidence for use of spironolactone in women with persistent acne (off-label use at present), which is also likely to take 3–6 months to work.

  • Maintenance topical treatment should be continued when discontinuing oral treatments.

Introduction

Acne vulgaris (hereafter referred to as acne) is extremely common, affecting over 90% of teenagers.1 Among people with acne, approximately 40%–60% have acne persisting into their twenties and it leads to some degree of scarring in approximately 20% of the population.2 3 Acne can cause significant distress, decreased self-confidence and increased rates of depression and suicidal thoughts,2 particularly among women and people identifying as non-white.4

As well as limiting quality of life, acne makes a major contribution to antibiotic use among young people: long courses of oral antibiotics are common and acne accounts for the majority of antibiotic exposure among people aged 11–21 years in England.5 There is high-quality evidence supporting use of topical treatments for acne, which are recommended as first line treatment for mild-to-moderate acne.6 However, treatment adherence is low and barriers to effective self-management include people discontinuing treatment early due to skin irritation or not seeing early treatment effects, and not differentiating between effective topical treatments and ineffective cosmetic products.7 Healthcare professionals need to promote treatment adherence by advising about delayed onset of action and how to avoid skin irritation.8 Providing information to patients is therefore crucial and the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence’s (NICE) guideline provides a list of information that should be provided for people with acne (see table 1). This may be difficult to cover in brief consultations, highlighting the need for signposting patients towards evidence-based resources, such as those listed in box 1.

Table 1

Summary of information for people with acne, based on NICE guidance

Box 1

Information resources for patients

Pathogenesis of acne

Acne is primarily a condition affecting the pilosebaceous unit (hair follicles in the skin and associated oil glands), leading to inflammatory and non-inflammatory lesions and scarring, most commonly affecting the face but also the trunk.2 The aetiology remains unclear but research into dietary, hygiene or other lifestyle causes have shown these to have little influence.2 However, public perceptions around the role of diet and hygiene are linked with perceived stigma around acne.8

Severe acne and acne scarring have a genetic component, although the specific at-risk genes have not been identified.2 Therefore, asking about a family history of acne scarring, acne affecting the back, and family members requiring treatment with isotretinoin is helpful.

Acne is associated with hyperandrogenism and is more common among people with polycystic ovary syndrome, as well as rarer conditions such as adrenal hyperplasia and adrenal tumours.9

Some medications may exacerbate acne, most importantly progesterone-only contraception, but also anabolic steroids, prednisolone, some antiepileptics and lithium.10 Greasy topical products, such as ointments, which occlude the hair follicles, increased sweating and occlusive clothing can also trigger acne.

Clinical features and diagnosis

The diagnosis of acne is made on the clinical history and examination. There are no diagnostic criteria and the skin lesions seen are open comedones (whiteheads), closed comedones (blackheads), papules/nodules, cysts and scarring.11 There is no strong evidence base for different treatments for different acne subtypes (comedonal vs inflammatory), and NICE and most other guidelines provide different guidance on the basis of severity rather than acne subtypes.12 While classifications vary, the majority of acne is mild, with moderate or severe acne combined making up less than 15% of cases of acne.3 13 See table 2 for severity classifications and linked treatment choices.

Table 2

Summary based on NICE guidance on first-line treatments for acne

Treatment options and guidelines

International guidelines recommend either topical benzoyl peroxide or topical retinoid (mainly adapalene) as first line treatments, but with differences regarding prescribing products individually or as combination products.12 The NICE guideline on acne, based on systematic review and network meta-analysis comparisons of acne treatments, acknowledged uncertainty in the evidence base and recommended the options in table 2 as first-line treatments.14 15

Topical treatments

First-line treatments for mild or moderate acne are fixed combination topical preparations containing retinoids, benzoyl peroxide or topical antibiotics, as outlined in table 2.16–18 It is important that patients understand that these have a delayed onset of action (6–8 weeks) and are aware of how to avoid skin irritation when starting treatment (table 1).

Oral antibiotic treatments

The NICE guideline recommends limiting oral antibiotics to 3–6 months, while other guidelines suggest a maximum duration 3 months in order to avoid emergence of antibiotic resistance.12 14 16–18 First-line oral antibiotic recommendations are lymecycline or doxycycline. If these are not tolerated or are contraindicated, the NICE guideline recommends that trimethoprim or an oral macrolide may be considered.14 However, clinicians report barriers to discontinuing oral antibiotics once they have been started including patients’ understandable concerns about acne relapse.19 Monotherapy with an oral or topical antibiotic should not be used, because there is good evidence that antimicrobial resistance is significantly reduced by coprescribing benzoyl peroxide.20 Consensus from clinical guidelines is that continuing topical treatments as maintenance therapy after discontinuing oral antibiotics is important in reducing the risk of relapse.12

Hormonal treatments

Hormonal treatments are an alternative for women with acne. Except for co-cyprindiol, hormonal treatments (combined oral contraceptives [COCs] or spironolactone) have an advantage over oral antibiotics and isotretinoin in that they can be continued for longer courses.

Combined oral contraceptives

COCs remain an option for women (‘off-label’ use in acne). Although inferior to oral antibiotics at 3 months, COCs are equivalent to antibiotics at reducing acne at 6 months.21 There is no firm evidence to support the use of any one COC over another in terms of acne.22

Co-cyprindiol

Co-cyprindiol 2000/35 (cyproterone acetate 2 mg, ethinylestradiol 35 µg) is licensed as a second-line treatment for women with severe acne, but is not recommended for long-term use due to safety concerns about rare, but cumulative dose-dependent, increased risk of meningioma.23

Spironolactone for adult women

The results of the spironolactone for adult female acne trial, published in The BMJ in 2023, showed that oral spironolactone alongside topical treatment is effective for improving outcomes for women with persistent acne, with greater effects seen at 6 months than 3 months.24 25 Spironolactone was well-tolerated starting at a dose of 50 mg increasing to 100 mg per day, although higher doses can be associated with adverse effects, particularly menstrual irregularity.24 26 Previous small trials suggest that the effectiveness of spironolactone may be similar to oral tetracycline for acne, but comparable data are limited.26 Ongoing trials of spironolactone compared with oral tetracycline for acne mean that more information should be available in the next few years.27 28

Baseline check of renal function and potassium levels is advised prior to starting spironolactone for acne.17 However, large observational studies show that abnormal renal function or potassium levels are very unusual in this population.29 Ongoing monitoring is unnecessary for most young women and has recently been advocated just for women aged over 45 years.17 29 Spironolactone is less teratogenic than oral tetracyclines commonly used for acne, so it would be appropriate for spironolactone to be treated with no special restriction beyond contraceptive counselling, as is the case for oral tetracyclines.30

Spironolactone is not currently licensed for the treatment of acne. However, the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) advises that clinicians can use a licensed medicine outside the terms of its licence (off-label prescribing) if they are satisfied that this is in the best interest of the patient, an alternative, licensed medicine would not meet the patient’s needs and there is sufficient safety and efficacy evidence.31 In addition, the prescriber should take responsibility for prescribing the medicine and for overseeing the patient’s care, including monitoring and follow-up.

Isotretinoin

The oral retinoid isotretinoin is used for treating severe acne. It was originally marketed under the brand name Roaccutane. The MHRA licensed indication for isotretinoin is for severe forms of acne (such as nodular or conglobate acne, or acne that is at risk of permanent scarring) that is resistant to adequate courses of standard therapy with systemic antibacterials and topical therapy.23 32 The licence states that it should only be prescribed by or under the supervision of physicians with expertise in the use of systemic retinoids for the treatment of severe acne and a full understanding of the risks of isotretinoin therapy and monitoring requirements. The MHRA has defined the groups of healthcare professionals who can take the role of Lead Prescriber in making the decision to initiate isotretinoin treatment following a face-to-face assessment with the patient.32

Acne conglobate (severe nodular cystic acne) and acne fulminans (acne conglobate with systemic symptoms) require urgent specialist dermatology review and potentially earlier treatment with isotretinoin. Otherwise, it is first necessary to follow the stepwise management of acne recommended in the NICE guidance.

Isotretinoin is an effective treatment for severe acne.14 There are a number of known and potential adverse effects associated with treatment.33 Most people will experience dryness of the skin and lips, which can be helped by emollients and lip balm, and a flare in acne is common at the start of treatment.33 Both of these adverse effects are dose dependent. Blood abnormalities are reasonably common, but in healthy people are usually not serious.34

Isotretinoin is highly teratogenic, and therefore, pregnancy must be avoided during treatment and for 1 month after stopping. All people with childbearing potential (people who may be able to become pregnant) must be entered into the Pregnancy Prevention Programme (PPP).

Psychiatric and sexual dysfunction adverse effects are the focus of an Expert Working Group of the Commission on Human Medicines report and have led to new MHRA guidance.32 The effect of isotretinoin on mood remains controversial; new population based studies have not shown an increased risk of suicide, however, there are reports of individual distressing cases.35 The MHRA has recommended better provision of information to patients regarding possible risk of mental health and sexual function adverse effects; standardised assessment of mental health prior to starting and improved monitoring for adverse effects while on treatment.32 Patients under the age of 18 years require two health professionals to agree their acne is severe and that isotretinoin is the most appropriate treatment before initiation of isotretinoin therapy. The aim of these changes is to improve the safety of isotretinoin for the treatment of acne.

New compulsory risk minimisation materials have been developed including an Acknowledgement of Risk form for all patients (which includes the PPP for appropriate patients), a Patient Reminder Card and a Pharmacist checklist. These materials are produced and circulated by the Market Authorisation holders. Patient information and other supporting and training resources are freely available on the British Association of Dermatologists Isotretinoin Clinical Resources webpage (https://www.bad.org.uk/guidelines-and-standards/isotretinoin-clinical-resources/).

In the future, new studies are needed to further investigate these potential adverse effects, including the effect of a reduced isotretinoin dose on effectiveness and reduction of potential harms.36

Management of acne in skin of colour

The NICE guidance does not provide different treatment recommendations for acne in skin of colour. Postinflammatory hyperpigmentation and scarring are more frequent and a particular concern for people with skin of colour and acne, and both atrophic and keloid scarring have been reported to be more common.37 It is important to avoid significant irritation with acne treatments, as this can worsen hyperpigmentation, but topical retinoids and azelaic acid can help both acne and hyperpigmentation.38

When to refer patients

Urgent (same day) referral is required for acne fulminans (acne conglobata associated with systemic symptoms).

Specialist referral is recommended by NICE for:

  • Nodulocystic acne or acne conglobata (severe nodulocystic acne with interconnecting sinuses and abscesses).

  • Diagnostic uncertainty.

  • Mild to moderate acne that has not responded to two completed courses of treatment (see table 2).

  • Moderate to severe acne which has not responded to treatment that includes an oral antibiotic.

  • Acne scarring or persistent pigmentary changes.

  • Acne contributing to persistent psychological distress or mental health disorder.

  • Acne linked to medication use, including self-administered anabolic steroids.

Pharmacy management of acne

NHS England describes mild acne as a condition appropriate for self-management with community pharmacy advice and use of over-the-counter medicines.39 Effective topical treatment (benzoyl peroxide) is available via community pharmacies and many offer advice about acne.40

Conclusion

Early effective treatment for acne improves patient well-being and may prevent permanent scars or pigment changes. Initial management includes a range of topical treatments, with the option of adding oral antibiotics for patients with more severe acne. There are significant opportunities for reducing oral antibiotic prescribing in acne. These include: promoting effective use of topical treatments; avoiding prolonged courses of oral antibiotics; coprescribing topical treatments alongside oral antibiotics; continuing topical treatments as maintenance treatment and considering alternatives, such as the combined contraceptive pill and spironolactone in primary care. When acne is unresponsive to these measures, timely referral for consideration of isotretinoin should be initiated.

Supplemental material

Supplemental material

Supplemental material

References

Footnotes

  • Competing interests None declared. Refer to the online supplementary files to view the ICMJE form(s).

  • Provenance and peer review Commissioned; externally peer reviewed.

  • Supplemental material This content has been supplied by the author(s). It has not been vetted by BMJ Publishing Group Limited (BMJ) and may not have been peer-reviewed. Any opinions or recommendations discussed are solely those of the author(s) and are not endorsed by BMJ. BMJ disclaims all liability and responsibility arising from any reliance placed on the content. Where the content includes any translated material, BMJ does not warrant the accuracy and reliability of the translations (including but not limited to local regulations, clinical guidelines, terminology, drug names and drug dosages), and is not responsible for any error and/or omissions arising from translation and adaptation or otherwise.